Sunday, August 8, 2021

A Reason that there is no Effective Leadership in American Evangelicalism

What follows this paragraph is a sentence from a Wall Street Journal article from a week or so ago detailing reasons white Evangelicals are being vaccinated for COVID at a lower rate than much of the rest of the American population. In my opinion, a substantial book could be written on the Journal's observation. 

"Some evangelical leaders are afraid their churches will lose members or donations if they openly support vaccination, said Curtis Chang, a former evangelical pastor who co-founded Christians and the Vaccine, a project designed to increase vaccine acceptance."

If you are a long term reader of my blogs, you know that I reject the notion that humans can be leaders in the Kingdom of God. In a kingdom, there's only one leader: The King. In a kingdom, everyone apart from the king is a servant of the crown. In a kingdom the appropriate question is not, "How can I be a better leader," the only acceptable question is?, "How can I better serve my king?"

If you are a long term reader of my blogs, you know that I point out that our very modern era in which people have fretted about Christian leadership has been disastrous and has resulted in Christianity losing Western culture. 

If you are a long term reader of my blogs, you know that I have bruised my fingers typing that Jesus said that the greatest person in the Kingdom will be the slave of all and that greatness, in general, is not a function of being a leader but of being a servant. 

If you are a long term reader of my blogs, you know that the challenge of Jesus was not, "Come, let me lead you," but, "Come, follow me." I've said that it would be appropriate to invent the term followership for life in the Kingdom but not to adopt the secular term leadership. 

If you are a long term reader of my blogs you know that, after the ascension, the people whose ministries, through the power and blessing of the Holy Spirit, propelled the expansion of the Gospel into the world, spoke of themselves as servants of Jesus, never leaders of the church. 

And, if you are a long term reader of my blogs you know that perhaps my most fervent criticism of the clergy/laity divide in the modern church is that the clergy has become the providers of religious products and services to be consumed by the laity. 

It's this last of my harangues that the Wall Street Journal article illustrates. 

The people who are followed in today's church are not the ordained and licensed members of the clergy but the people whose primary role is to consume, the people who determine which "church" is successful by the standards of the world because they sit their fannies in seats and they open their purses and wallets to pay the bills.

Members of the clergy today are dependent on their congregations to pay their salaries. The bottom line in the church today is that, nearly every successful member of the clergy, that is, the "pastors" who can afford a nice home and car, know how to dance to the music their congregations want to hear...

...and, no matter what the truth about COVID vaccines may be one way or the other, as the Wall Street Journal points out, a prominent reason that evangelical pastors are not speaking forcefully and with vision about COVID vaccines is fear that the consumers in their congregations won't want  to consume that message and that they'll plant their fannies and open their wallets and purses next week at the church where the pastor is clearly an anti-vaxxer. 

In today's evangelical world, members of the clergy have become providers of the religious products and services that please the consumers in the laity they service. 

This ain't right.  In fact, it's very, very wrong.

It most certainly is not the way of Jesus. 

If you can't understand how the Gospel that proclaims the Lord of all authority and power and grace and mercy and blessing is losing the culture, understand. This is one very important reason. 

My Five Greatest Heroes from the History of the Kingdom

A few days ago, a friend sent me a link to a Vimeo video by Evangelical Seminary (my alma mater) President Tony Blair entitled, How the Pietists Made Disciples

I watched it. It's awesome, but it was all the more fascinating to me because the video traced Pietist disciplining strategies to the seventeenth century German minister Philipp Jakob Spener. 

It turns out that, years ago, I began to ask myself who, among all the great heroes of the Christian faith, inspires me most: My Five Greatest Heroes from "Church History"...

...and, Philipp Jakob Spener made my list.

I settled on this list in a relatively short time and the membership of the list has remained the same for a long time even though, for my own amusement, I have reconsidered it many times.

Some of these names are relatively obscure. Spener is probably the most obscure but there are no Luthers or Calvins here. 

Here's the list in chronological order. The characteristics that set these (they are all) men, apart, and which I greatly admire, are  that they all attacked an existing paradigm and they all advocated for radically righteous lives. These are, of course, characteristics I aspire to, hence the fact that they are heroes to me personally. 

1. Tertullian (155?-220?)

2. Philipp Jakob Spener (1635-1705)

3. John Winebrenner (1797-1860)-well, I am still in love with the Church of God 

4. Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855)

5. Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906-1945)

My guess is that no one who reads this blog would be amused for a nanosecond by creating a list of greatest Christian heroes. But, if you have thoughts...

...on or off the blog, of course.

Sunday, August 1, 2021

We "Went to 'Church'" Today

It's been a looooooong time since we walked into a church building on a Sunday morning to, uh, go to church

We're into what today, apparently, is faddishly now called "micro." When we began it, it was called House Church, then, later, Simple Church. 

I can't account for how long ago we last "attended church." I will admit to watching a church, ouch, "service" on line from time to time but, even then, that was mostly during the "two weeks to flatten the curve" (Wasn't that a joke? The longest two weeks of MY life).

A friend of ours whom we've been disciplining or, as Lance would say, I've been fathering...we have been spiritually parenting...was showing slides of and discussing a mission trip to Uganda at her church. We went to support her.

Going was especially traumatic for Evie who has never really been edified by what passes as church services. Several times yesterday she let go, unconsciously, a long, heavy sigh. After the first one I asked what was vexing her. She said, "Church tomorrow," and after that, I understood. 

(Just a quick note: I don't think many church people realize how far the standard twenty first century church experience has diverted from what is biblical as far as the gathering of disciples is concerned, let alone what is essential to building up each other.) Doing the Sunday morning thing doesn't edify her. At best, it's a neutral influence on her walk. Worse case, it actually impairs her life of obedience. 

It's little wonder to us that the group called the "Nones" grows so rapidly. It's possible, easy in fact, to be all about Jesus and even to love His Body but to be unconnected to the organized and institutionalized church. 

Anyway, out of love for our friend Elizabeth, we went.

A few observations. 

1. There were about 125 people present. Evie and I may very well have been the oldest people there. Clearly, this was not a CGGC gathering. There were many of youth age, lots of twentysomethings and thirtysomethings. And, surprisingly, a lot of males...perhaps even more than females. I'm not sure how to account for that. Apparently, one of the things this group DOES is intentionally connect with people who commit felonies. Most felons, I suspect, are men, so...

2. This group is guilty of the same theological atrocity that most low church evangelical-ish groups commit. They call, and think of, their music time as "worship." That's not what worship is. In truth, in the New Covenant, to worship is to offer your body as a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God. (Rom. 12:1) I wore out the finger prints on several of my fingers typing that out and entering it on Brian Miller's Emerging CGGC blog back in the day. Anyway, they worshiped for about 20 minutes. Contemporary music. A five piece band. Not very polished but the members of the band seemed authentic in "leading worship," not performing. 

3. The sermon was topical, not expositional. It was broadly on spiritual warfare, I think. Again, the preacher oozed authenticity. He preached for about 45 minutes and then invited others to give testimonies, which several did. This is not an introvert church.

As you probably know, I believe that Jesus "gave some to be apostles, others to be prophets, others to be evangelists and others to be shepherds and teachers..." (Eph. 4:11) You can choose to think that that truth is no longer applicable to our day but when I listen to a sermon, it's usually easy to hear the fruit of an APEST calling. It's a bit of a hobby for me to examine APEST fruit in a preacher and sermon.

This guy was, to me, an interesting study. From word one he connected biblical truth directly to lifestyle. He had three points, of course. (After all, if a three point sermon was good enough for Jesus, it's good enough for me!). Anyway, in points two and three he declared specifically the necessity that we repent. And, shiver me timbers, when he commented on one of the testimonies, he quoted the verse I wear out on this blog, 2 Corinthians 7:10: "For godly sorrow produces a repentance that leads to salvation..."

Yikes! This guy is a prophet!


So,...

We went to church...to support Elizabeth. No doubt, we'll do that again...

I love Jesus. He still amazes me. I'm probably more in awe of His incarnation and our redemption through Him than I have ever been. 

I love the body of believers. I love the fellowship of the saints, but, the organized and institutionalized church? What it does when it gathers? Not so much.

I wish that the organized and institutionalized church edified us more. I  wish the usual church gatherings "spurred us on to love and good works" and promoted Romans 12:1 worship for us more than they do.

But, after today?...